After applying I loved how well easy it was to apply and it looked fabulous. Hours later my eye started to itch and when I looked in the mirror it was swelling. I immediately removed the eyeliner. One eye continued to swell. Took Benadryl in hopes it would counteract the allergic reaction. In the morning the swelling was down a little but more swelling appeared under my eye. It looked like I had been punched. Plan to apply cold compress to eyes and continue with Benadryl. This is an absolute first for me. Never had a reaction to eye makeup in my life. Extremely disappointed in this product. Wondering what is in it to cause such a severe reaction. Be aware!!!
Consumer Reviews and Complaints
WRITE A REVIEWRate and Write a Review on Maybelline New York
Juan Ocampo-Wells Fargo Bank
I entered the bank with the purpose to do business. Found out that I was unable to deposit cash into another account. Had just been at the
Allure Aesthetics Inc
We are a 2nd plastic surgery clinic in SF, that fell into a trap of purchasing a medical equipment in June 2017 from Troy Johnson of
Fyves Advertising Media
I also ordered a pair of detroit lions shoes for my husband back in April. I contacted the company who stated that the shoes were special
Happy Herbalist
Previous Review Next Review
Fremin’s Contractor Services, LLC.
This company is a rip off. They hide unethical behavior behind their God Bless crap. We performed work for them for a while then they
Arizona Auto Wash
OMG! This place is HORRIBLE! If you want to be harrassed, and your personal info taken OUT of your car, and LOST or SOLD-GO HERE! The
Eileen Gustafson
My name is Eileen Gustafson and I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker. I graduated from the University of South Florida in 1997. I have
DecorMyEyes.com / EyewearTown Corporation
Previous Review Next Review
This complaint and/or review was posted on HolySmoke.org on 12:52 pm, September 08, 2018 (CST) and is a permanent record located at: https://www.holysmoke.org/scam/maybelline-new-york/.
The reviews & complaints posted about Maybelline New York was submitted by a member or guest on this website. Any and all opinions and information are published as is. HolySmoke.org does not edit or remove any aspect of the report and is simply a consumer grievance free-speech platform. As such, HolySmoke.org cannot be held liable for the complaints and reviews posted about Maybelline New York as per Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act.
Maybelline New York Reviews & Complaints
After applying I loved how well easy it was to apply and it looked fabulous. Hours later my eye started to itch and when I looked in the mirror it was swelling. I immediately removed the eyeliner. One eye continued to swell. Took Benadryl in hopes it would counteract the allergic reaction. In the morning the swelling was down a little but more swelling appeared under my eye. It looked like I had been punched. Plan to apply cold compress to eyes and continue with Benadryl. This is an absolute first for me. Never had a reaction to eye makeup in my life. Extremely disappointed in this product. Wondering what is in it to cause such a severe reaction. Be aware!!!
Maybelline New York Reviews & Complaints
Hello maybelline! I would like to register the dissatisfaction I just had when opening a Lipstick of your brand. it is wrapped and sealed and when I opened it it was all scratched with some strange marks and the top was as if it had been cut. I was very sad because this was the first lipstick of your brand that I bought and now I have to throw it away. I can’t use something that might be contaminated. I’m sending pictures of lipstick the moment I opened it. I really liked to know what are you gonna do about that.
Maybelline New York Reviews & Complaints
Hello maybelline! I would like to register the dissatisfaction I just had when opening a Lipstick of your brand. it is wrapped and sealed and when I opened it it was all scratched with some strange marks and the top was as if it had been cut. I was very sad because this was the first lipstick of your brand that I bought and now I have to throw it away. I can’t use something that might be contaminated. I’m sending pictures of lipstick the moment I opened it. I really liked to know what are you gonna do about that.
Maybelline New York Reviews & Complaints
Hello! Im a regular user of maybelline lipstick and last week, before your sale, I have asked the price of 1 super stay lipstick and the price is p299.00, then somebody told me that youre going to have a sale on aug. 16, 17, 18.. I know that is you use a prestige card for friday sale, you will have a 10%-10% disct.. So ive waited for it. Then yesterday I purchase my lipstick, hoping to get a disct of 10%-10% and I was dismay coz the price has changed into p349.00 instead of p299.00 and less 10% only.. My question is why do you change your price and then give a smaller disct.. Youres is 349- 50= 299 less 10%, its should be p299-10%-10%.. You always do that to your customers not only a lipstick, but everything. This is so unfair.. The people doesnt know your trick to attract customers..
Maybelline New York Reviews & Complaints
Hello! Im a regular user of maybelline lipstick and last week, before your sale, I have asked the price of 1 super stay lipstick and the price is p299.00, then somebody told me that youre going to have a sale on aug. 16, 17, 18.. I know that is you use a prestige card for friday sale, you will have a 10%-10% disct.. So ive waited for it. Then yesterday I purchase my lipstick, hoping to get a disct of 10%-10% and I was dismay coz the price has changed into p349.00 instead of p299.00 and less 10% only.. My question is why do you change your price and then give a smaller disct.. Youres is 349- 50= 299 less 10%, its should be p299-10%-10%.. You always do that to your customers not only a lipstick, but everything. This is so unfair.. The people doesnt know your trick to attract customers..
Maybelline New York Reviews & Complaints
I bought a newyork babylips cherry lip balm today at a Big Bazaar Store(India) for the first time as friends had suggested it many times. The new lip balm ended up to be broken and hollow when opened. This has really turned me off towards maybelline itself as this lip balm was the first product I bought from maybelline. Would never suggest or buy a product again from maybelline as this experience was really bad. Selling a hollow lip balm for 175 rupees was a bad idea maybelline. I would look forward to a refund or an exchange from you as soon as possible.
Maybelline New York Reviews & Complaints
I bought a newyork babylips cherry lip balm today at a Big Bazaar Store(India) for the first time as friends had suggested it many times. The new lip balm ended up to be broken and hollow when opened. This has really turned me off towards maybelline itself as this lip balm was the first product I bought from maybelline. Would never suggest or buy a product again from maybelline as this experience was really bad. Selling a hollow lip balm for 175 rupees was a bad idea maybelline. I would look forward to a refund or an exchange from you as soon as possible.
Maybelline New York Reviews & Complaints
I decided to try out maybellines copper eyeliner gel and immediately after putting it on my eyes started to get this terrible stinging feeling along with a burning sensation that felt like my eyes were on fire. After about an hour of bearing through it I couldn’t handle the pain anymore so I used makeup removal wipes to take it off. It still burned a great deal after taking it off. I then took a shower and washed my face several times since. Now nearly 6 hours later my eyes still feel like they are on fire, I also noticed they started to turn red as well as the skin around my eyes as well as my eyelids. They are also tearing up like crazy. When will this hoirrble burning sensation end??! It is insane to me that they would have a product like this on the shelves! My advice is to never buy a maybelline eyeliner unless you want to feel like someone set fire to your eyeballs.
Maybelline New York Reviews & Complaints
I decided to try out maybellines copper eyeliner gel and immediately after putting it on my eyes started to get this terrible stinging feeling along with a burning sensation that felt like my eyes were on fire. After about an hour of bearing through it I couldn’t handle the pain anymore so I used makeup removal wipes to take it off. It still burned a great deal after taking it off. I then took a shower and washed my face several times since. Now nearly 6 hours later my eyes still feel like they are on fire, I also noticed they started to turn red as well as the skin around my eyes as well as my eyelids. They are also tearing up like crazy. When will this hoirrble burning sensation end??! It is insane to me that they would have a product like this on the shelves! My advice is to never buy a maybelline eyeliner unless you want to feel like someone set fire to your eyeballs.
Maybelline New York Reviews & Complaints
I have been using your Maybelline 16 hour makeup for a leats 1 and half years or longer. and when you changed it to 24 hour makeup it is not as good. In fact, it is too thin in addition, I also started using your new waterproof Siloutte Mascara, well it is not that waterproof. In my opinion, why doesn”t the company maybelline Cosmetics invent a makeup with flawless cover 16 to 24 hours that even covers the dark circles under one”s eyes, yes you do have the 24 concealer, but it just seems to sink right into your skin, does not cover very well at all. I know a lot of women turn to Plastic Surgery but that is one thing that I do not believe in even if I could afford it. Please make your makeup for a older women also that does not make them look old and covers like I said flawlessly, right down to the dark circles. I know that such a makeup can be invented because a long time ago Mary Kaye makeup had one, of course today well I will not say anything at this time about Mary Kaye Makeup. Please improve your makeup and Masacra. Sincerely Margie
Maybelline New York Reviews & Complaints
I have been using your Maybelline 16 hour makeup for a leats 1 and half years or longer. and when you changed it to 24 hour makeup it is not as good. In fact, it is too thin in addition, I also started using your new waterproof Siloutte Mascara, well it is not that waterproof. In my opinion, why doesn”t the company maybelline Cosmetics invent a makeup with flawless cover 16 to 24 hours that even covers the dark circles under one”s eyes, yes you do have the 24 concealer, but it just seems to sink right into your skin, does not cover very well at all. I know a lot of women turn to Plastic Surgery but that is one thing that I do not believe in even if I could afford it. Please make your makeup for a older women also that does not make them look old and covers like I said flawlessly, right down to the dark circles. I know that such a makeup can be invented because a long time ago Mary Kaye makeup had one, of course today well I will not say anything at this time about Mary Kaye Makeup. Please improve your makeup and Masacra. Sincerely Margie
Maybelline New York Reviews & Complaints
I received mascara that was not sealed. I contacted customer service that said that they sent it out sealed. They said that I should not worry about using the product, however the plastic on the back of the cardboard was not in tact at delivery. The mascara itself had no protective seal. Customer service said that I can return the product at my own expense, since they would not take any responsibility for possible damage of the packaging during delivery, but they would refund me the purchase price. Every warning tells you not to use cosmetics that have been opened. This product is for use on my eyes. I wonder if they would take responsibility if I were to suffer vision problems from infection or worse. TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE. For all I know this is a used product.
Maybelline New York Reviews & Complaints
I received mascara that was not sealed. I contacted customer service that said that they sent it out sealed. They said that I should not worry about using the product, however the plastic on the back of the cardboard was not in tact at delivery. The mascara itself had no protective seal. Customer service said that I can return the product at my own expense, since they would not take any responsibility for possible damage of the packaging during delivery, but they would refund me the purchase price. Every warning tells you not to use cosmetics that have been opened. This product is for use on my eyes. I wonder if they would take responsibility if I were to suffer vision problems from infection or worse. TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE. For all I know this is a used product.
Maybelline New York Reviews & Complaints
I usually dont complain and because I cant find a website to complain to maybelline direct I will do it here. My mother and I purchased 2 of the new define-a-lash waterproof mascaras to give them a go, and when we took them home and opened them within a week of purchasing we found that neither of them has a brush for us to actually use them, of course we didnt keep the receipt from the store as we thought what could possibly be wrong with mascara, so we could not get any exchange let alone refund not impressed, how many people have had this problem and waste there hard earned money that is for some, difficult to come by these days.